TED O’BRIEN
SHADOW MINISTER FOR FOREIGN AFFAIRS
FEDERAL MEMBER FOR FAIRFAX
TRANSCRIPT
NEWS 24
SUNDAY AGENDA WITH ANDREW CLENNELL
25 October 2026
E&OE………………………………
Speakers: Ted O’Brien MP & Andrew Clennell
Topics: Helen Haines, MP safety, Labor Pork Barreling, EU FTA, One Nation.
Andrew Clennell
Shadow Foreign Minister Ted O'Brien, thanks for your time, Ted O'Brien. I might start with a question I was going to ask Catherine King, but didn't get to it because I had to talk about grants a fair bit. This video, I don't know if you saw it. I played a couple of videos at the top of the show from the Pauline Hanson 'Please Explain' videos. They show her running over the Prime Minister and National Party members and Lydia Thorpe, it's not very helpful. This sort of stuff, is it?
Ted O'Brien
No, certainly not timely. Admittedly, Andrew, I actually haven't seen the videos. Not that I wasn't interested in watching your show this morning, by the way. But look, I think, especially given what's happened with Helen Haines last week, I think it is a time for all of us to be pausing to look at how we operate, especially as politicians, and ask questions of ourselves: Is this appropriate in the current climate? That, no doubt, will be a question that Senator Hanson and Pauline will just she'll just have to make that call for herself.
Andrew Clennell
What's your reaction to the Helen Haines attack, and do you think there's an argument for greater protection for parliamentarians, or you know you can't guard against every potential threat?
Ted O'Brien
Well, the good news, Andrew, is by reports Helen's position now, her condition has stabilized. I think that's good news. The agencies are looking at how to improve security for MPs and their staff. I think that is important, but it's a tough one for them, to be honest. It's complicated because we have to strengthen security without weakening democracy. And so, as a local MP, I don't want to stop going to community events. I don't want to stop pitching a marquee standing under it and having constituents just coming up freely. That open access is a cornerstone of democracy. We're particularly good at it in Australia. We can't take away grassroots politics, which is why it is complicated for the security agencies to work out how do we keep these MPs and senators safe? How do we ensure their staff are safe? That's what they're looking at now, particularly in the aftermath of last week's tragedy that impacted Helen. Let's wait to see what they come up with. I think there's probably a deeper issue here too, Andrew, which isn't a matter for the agencies; it's a matter for us in Parliament. You know, we have serious issues with social cohesion breaking down. We've got an enormous amount of division, we have Australians hurting, whether it be due to sliding living standards, whether it be loneliness. These are things that ultimately Parliament has to look at. They are deeper issues, more systemic issues, and we have to ensure that where we can rebuild civil society, we do.
Andrew Clennell
Have you yourself ever had security concerns? How difficult is it for MPs to deal with mentally ill people at electorate offices?
Ted O'Brien
It is difficult. It's particularly difficult for staff. They are on the front line. When we're in Parliament, we're doing media, all these sorts of things. Often, it is actually the electorate office staff who carry the load, and they're dealing with it every single day. Have I needed security at times? Yes, I've certainly gone to events, not in my own electorate, but in capital cities where I have needed the Australian Federal Police detail to protect me going in, going out of certain venues. I have had to improve the security at my private home on advice, as well as improve the security of my electorate office on advice, and so I think it does impact everybody. And it's one of those, you know, that old saying, you know, you need to be alert but not alarmed. That's certainly the way I look at this. We can't be complacent about it, but you have to also get on with your job, which ultimately is serving others and being accessible to them, Andrew.
Andrew Clennell
Did you have to pay for your home security just briefly?
Ted O'Brien
At my home, yes.
Andrew Clennell
What sort of week are you expecting in Parliament as a result of this?
Ted O'Brien
I think Parliament will do the right thing. I think Parliament will, across the board, come together and focus on Helen, on her husband, on Phil, her husband, the family. I think too that we will all start reflecting on what it is we can do differently as a parliament, but also as individuals, you know, last week was such a tragedy, and I think of Helen is going to live with the consequences every single day of her life, and I think that demands the nation does pause and think about how we can do things better, how we. Can debate better. Robust debate is fundamental to our system, but personal nastiness is not. We've got to make sure that we can address this.
Andrew Clennell
Fair enough. Well, this so-called dirt sheet the PM's office put out on Helen Haines, trying to get grants. What's your view of that?
Ted O'Brien
I was disappointed that the Prime Minister isn't upfront and honest about it, Andrew. That was my initial reaction. You know, clearly they put out all of this information from his office to rebut Helen Haines. You know, call it a dirt sheet, call it whatever you want, but you know, for the Prime Minister to pretend it was a compliment to Helen Haines at the very same time he's asking people to raise the standards of behavior. I mean, seriously, I think that goes to the character, unfortunately, of the Prime Minister. You know, you can't be halfway throwing a punch, get caught, and then pretend it's a hug, and that's what the Prime Minister tried to do. And it's really unfortunate because we need leadership right now. He has responsibility, and I hope he stands up and holds himself to account.
Andrew Clennell
So you think you should say, "Look, we put this out, I was obviously pointing out Helen Haines goes for grants too. I wish I hadn't put it out. I regret it." You think you should say something like that?
Ted O'Brien
Yeah, exactly, exactly. I don't think it needs any more than that. I mean, just just be upfront. Australians aren't fools. They can sniff through fakes. They can sniff through a fib pretty quickly. Just just be upfront. No one's perfect, right, Andrew? You're not. God knows I'm not. And so I just think the Australian people are pretty forgiving, so long as you're upfront with them. I think that's the real test, especially when it comes to the test of leadership. And if you are going to be the Prime Minister of this country, being upfront and honest really should be the first prerequisite.
Andrew Clennell
See, on these grants, Catherine King just admitted that Labor's head office was involved in drawing them up. So it's a taxpayer-funded program, but she's admitted Labor's head office was involved in this half a billion-dollar grants program. What do you make of that?
Ted O'Brien
To be honest, I've always seen the Parliamentary Labor Party as a subsidiary of other things, Andrew. Principally the Union movement. So it doesn't surprise me if they have their head office of the organizational wing calling the shots on taxpayer money. Unfortunately, that doesn't surprise me in the least.
Andrew Clennell
But what do you make of this practice? Because we are talking. I mean, she she says it's election promises, but what the minister is admitting, and I, you know, I congratulate her for being honest. We were just talking about honesty. Is that basically head office officials are involved with drawing up a program, dishing out all this money, taxpayer money that then goes through this formal process through a department? Is that? I mean, should that go to the National Anti-Corruption Commission? Should what should occur in relation to that?
Ted O'Brien
Well, it needs to be investigated as to who investigates it, I'll allow others more qualified than I to comment. But let me give you an example of my experience, Andrew, as a Liberal National Shadow Minister, in the last term of government, I held the climate and energy portfolio. Now, when my colleagues had a wish list, they wanted a project for to announce during the election, they all came to me. I had to assess those asks where I thought they were appropriate to match the need of an electorate. I would then have to take it to the shadow expenditure review committee, which was chaired by Peter Dutton. That's my personal experience on the Coalition side, with how a wish list was dealt with in in my previous portfolio, so if Labor is saying they do it differently, they give the wish list to the head office outside of Parliament. Head office processes it, they make the decisions, and they basically tell the government. That is for me highly inappropriate and needs to be investigated. And by the way, Andrew, can I just say, Catherine King wasn't honest with you. I'm not going to give her credit for that for being honest. I mean, she was saying that the Coalition's former community development program, we had grant program. Was the same as the one about which you and she were talking. No, it wasn't. The program that Labor has used was entirely closed, invitation only. No one else could come in. Where the Coalition had our community grants program, we certainly had election commitments delivered through it. But we also then opened it up beyond election commitments.
Andrew Clennell
Right.
Ted O'Brien
So you know the claim of equivalence is not an honest statement from Catherine King.
Andrew Clennell
Okay well, you've written to the foreign minister calling on her to renegotiate the EU free trade agreement. You've gone around Don. You've gone over the head of Trade Minister Don Farrell, what are the objections here from the opposition? Because the government says you're costing the economy huge access to European markets.
Ted O'Brien
Well, firstly, Andrew, I went to Penny Wong for a few reasons. Firstly, she was very vocal when she was in opposition, calling on the then Coalition government to engage with the then Labor opposition on free trade agreements, then it was the China FTA. I'm basically asking her to apply the same principle. She is also the Foreign Minister, and this gets to answering your question directly now. The deal that the Albanese government has negotiated with Europe includes two components. One is trade, and one is climate. The climate component is the subject about which I wrote to Penny Wong. That is an international treaty signing Australia up to legal obligations on climate change. This is the first time in history that Australia has sought to do so. It is unprecedented. They have basically taken the hottest political debate in Australia this century and plonked it in the center of a free trade agreement, seeking to weaponise an international treaty.
Andrew Clennell
It's in the UK FTA that you guys signed up to, the same thing?
Ted O'Brien
That's not right...
Andrew Clennell
The text notes each party affirms... The text notes each party affirms its commitment to address climate change, including under the UNFCCC Paris Agreement. That's what the UK FTA does. So how's this any different?
Ted O'Brien
Andrew. I don't blame you for for calling that out because I know Don Farrell and Labor are using that very line. But the UK agreement did not have the legal obligations that you see in the EU agreement. So firstly, what you just read out, you use the word 'affirms'. Now, you talk to any lawyer who's familiar with how contracts are done. 'Affirms a commitment' is very different from the EU commitment that basically says 'shall implement'. And then the EU commitment has another chapter. It's chapter 24 that makes it very clear: if Australia breaches these commitments under Paris, then there will be consequences put at risk. Of course, there's a dispute settlement process, but ultimately it exposes Australia to the possibility of the preferences through the deal being stalled. If you go to the DFAT website, so the Department of Foreign Affairs' own website, it makes it crystal clear that this is the first time that legally bound obligations are being made in an FTA by Australia with respect to climate. Now that's the department's own website. So, if you don't believe me, look at the department's website, which contradicts Labor's argument. There's equivalence with the UK agreement. There is not.
Andrew Clennell
Well, I think that debate will continue to rage. I revealed at the top of the show: people are going to One Nation because they're sick of scripted answers from politicians. Is it time some of you took. I mean, you're going pretty well in this interview, I think, Ted O'Brien. But is it time some of you took some more risks, and were a bit more honest and authentic with people out there?
Ted O'Brien
I'm all for authenticity, Andrew. When it comes to risks, so long as you're not risking things for the Australian people, right? And that's sort of that is a actually not just a flippant comment, you know. Politics is is serious stuff. You're representing the Australian people, so you don't want to just go out and say, you know what, I've got an idea. Let's let's go announce this. You've got to do the the heavy lifting. You've got to do the hard work. And I have to say, under Angus Taylor, you have seen a suite of policies coming out because the hard work's being done, and I think if you want to demonstrate your capacity to govern a country, you've got to do the hard work.
Andrew Clennell
Was it not being done under Sussan Ley? Was it not being done under Susan Lee when he was deputy?
Ted O'Brien
Certainly, hard work was being. Done under Sussan's leadership, but here we are now, halfway through the term, and you've seen Angus Taylor put his foot on the accelerator and absolutely focus on policy because we've got to get policy right.
Andrew Clennell
Okay, that's nearly out of time here. Are you concerned about losing your own seat to One Nation?
Ted O'Brien
Andrew, I came into Parliament, and my seat was the most marginal seat in the country, and that's because Clive Palmer had won it. Now we have One Nation. I don't take anything for granted. No MP should, by the way. You know, ultimately, it's not up to us. We've got to remember that. So, what can we do? Work our tail off for those we serve. If you fake it, they'll sniff it out. Just work your tail off. Be up front, and ultimately, it's their will that'll determine the outcome.
Andrew Clennell
Would you encourage Matt Canavan to run for the seat of Capricornia at the next election, even if it means taking on Pauline Hanson or James Ashby?
Ted O'Brien
I'm really going to miss Michelle Landry. Can I say from the outset. She's been an absolute champion, and boy has she copped it from the Labor Party over the years on the ground. She has stood strong. When it comes to Matt Canavan, Matt is doing a fantastic job leading the the Nationals. A fantastic colleague, also a fellow Queenslander, great colleague. How best can he make a contribution to the country he wants to serve, Andrew? That's the question. Matt is the only one who can really answer that, but I trust he'll make the right decision.
Andrew Clennell
Ted O'Brien, thanks for your time.