TED O’BRIEN
SHADOW MINISTER FOR FOREIGN AFFAIRS
FEDERAL MEMBER FOR FAIRFAX
TRANSCRIPT
4BC
BREAKFAST WITH JASON MATTHEWS
26 October 2026
Topics: EU FTA, Cash Payments.
E&O....................................................
Jason Matthews
The Albanese government is looking to introduce legally binding climate commitments in a free trade agreement with the European Union. The Opposition has raised concerns this could expose Australian businesses to the risk of severe penalties if we miss Labor's climate targets. In fact, Opposition Leader Angus Taylor said on this radio station yesterday that this deal stinks. Shadow Minister for Foreign Affairs, Ted O'Brien is calling on the government to negotiate a formal side letter to guarantee these protections. He joins us now to explain what this means for our economy. Good morning to you, Ted.
Ted O'Brien
Good morning, Jason.
Jason Matthews
What are your primary concerns regarding the climate commitments tied to this EU free trade agreement?
Ted O'Brien
So, Jason, I think most people would say Australia should do lots of trade if we're going to make more money. More trade means more jobs. So, you know, in principle, we don't mind the idea of a free trade agreement with Europe. But what the Albanese government has done is they've negotiated not just very poor outcomes with Europe on trade, but for the very first time, they've introduced a climate treaty inside a free trade agreement, and they did this in silence. They didn't tell the Australian people about it; they were secretive about it. And basically, what it does is it binds us legally as a country to climate targets, and if Australia misses the climate targets the Albanese government has sent through to the United Nations, or another government comes in, so the coalition government comes in and has a different set of policies with different emissions profile, it raises the risk that the preferences, the trade preferences given to Australia through this deal, could be suspended. In other words, our businesses, our producers, could be penalized if we change again, you know, change Labor's policies over time. And let's be clear: the Coalition has every intention of getting rid of Labor's energy policies. They are a disaster for our economy, and so this is setting us up as trying to bind our hands forevermore. And that's why the deal, as it stands today, just can't be accepted. So what I proposed is, when I put this to Labor, they said, "Don't worry about it. Everything's okay." And my view is, well, you can't have it both ways. If you think everything's okay, then let's have that in writing, agreed between Europe and Australia, confirming there is no risk should Australia not meet Labor's future climate targets. There is no risk should a future Australian government change its policies, so the ball's now in the government's court. We'll see whether or not they deliver.
Jason Matthews
Well, Trade Minister Don Farrell says this deal is no different from our agreement with the UK. Is he misleading Australians? And if so, is this deal different?
Ted O'Brien
Jason, he has been saying that, and unfortunately, he is misleading Australians. You know, it's one thing to keep this secret; it's another thing to then start telling porkie pies about it once it's revealed. There is no equivalence between a free trade agreement we did agree with the United Kingdom and this one with Europe. And here's the difference, right? When we did a deal with the UK, we had a political affirmation of our climate commitments, but in this one with Europe, for the very first time, we have legally binding commitments. Right, and I won't go through chapter and verse, which I'm have to do of of the actual contract. But here's the thing. Actually, if you go to DFAT, so the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, if you go to the actual department's website, it says it in black and white. This is the very first time that Australia has signed up to legally binding climate commitments. So any talk from Labor that it's like the UK deal is a complete untruth. It's misleading. In fact, it's a lie.
Jason Matthews
Okay, well, that's my homework today. I'll do that after the show. I read this morning that the Coalition wants to bring in a cash is king law. Can you just quickly describe what that law is?
Ted O'Brien
So I think, Jason, most Australians would assume they actually already have a right to pay with cash, but they don't. There's a general right when it comes to supermarkets and fuel stations within certain hours of the day. That's not fair. There's so many people who still use cash, and so we're putting forward a private members' bill through our financial services shadow minister Kevin Hogan that expands cash acceptance at major retailers, so chemists, hardware stores, department stores. If you want to use cash, you can still use cash, but we're also doing this in a way that protects small businesses, because you know it's a Coalition who fights for small businesses. So small businesses will have an exemption, but everyone else won't. Right.
Jason Matthews
Okay, so that means basically every business needs to accept cash.
Ted O'Brien
Yeah, that's right. Every business, other than small businesses, there are exemptions. If a senior citizen, you know, goes down to Bunnings, they need to have absolute protection that there's no chance in the future they can be denied paying in cash, you know that sort of thing.
Jason Matthews
Okay, well I can't see a problem with that. That should be fine. Should be fine. Parliament is back today, and this is the question of what I talked about is the dreadful attack we had on Helen Haines, and we keep learning more about this story every day. I've been told, and I'm hearing that you guys and the Labor Party in Parliament are going to be well behaved this week. Is that is that something you guys, well, both sides will promise? And how long will this last?
Ted O'Brien
Well, certainly, I expect, with the exception of most of today, where usual business will be suspended, other than question time, just so everyone can make speeches on Helen. As of tomorrow, Parliament will get back to robust debate, and I think that's needed, Jason. What I'm hoping, though, is we see some of the personal nastiness that might sometimes take place. That's the stuff that we've got to get rid of for good. But you know, well, I think so for good. I mean, that's exactly what should happen. I mean, you know, things get pretty passionate in the parliament, right? You're fighting for people.
Jason Matthews
But sometimes, Ted, it just gets ridiculous. It's like watching pre-schoolers play.
Ted O'Brien
Yeah, exactly. So this is the thing. So where there's nastiness, where there is clearly behaviour that is unacceptable, that's the sort of stuff we got to get rid of. And I've sort of been, you know, pointing to the fact that you do have school kids coming through, often you know, peering through a window on a school trip, and you know if they're doing that and they're all well behaved, and you've got Parliamentarians sort of screaming personal things at each other, it's completely the wrong example. But you can still have robust debate, and we have to. That's democracy. But you don't have to go into the gutter. That's what we need to get rid of.
Jason Matthews
Ted, one quick question I want to ask you before I go comes from one of my listeners, Myra. She says, "I'm confused with the Coalition's position on the EU deal. The deal requires a commitment to the Paris Agreement, which the Coalition are committed to. So I don't understand the opposition to the deal." Can you answer that for Myra?
Ted O'Brien
Yeah, sure, Myra. And it's a really good question. So under the Paris Agreement, you do not have a legally binding obligation to achieve targets. If a country does not achieve its targets, and you know around about half the G20 right now, no chance of achieving their targets. There's no actual penalty, and so what's different here is the government has signed up to this EU free trade agreement, and suddenly now they are legally bound. At least Australia becomes legally bound, and there are penalties, and so that's why it's completely different. It's taking what is a political commitment in the Paris Agreement into a legal commitment with penalties in the European Agreement, so very different consequences for Australia.
Jason Matthews
All right, Ted O'Brien, Shadow Minister for Foreign Affairs. Appreciate your time this morning. Behave yourself today.